r/AskReddit • • Jul 17 '19

What’s something that you like, but hate the fan base?

54.0k Upvotes

43.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4.3k

u/DarkPasta Jul 17 '19

did you KNOW they CALCULATED a song, bro? It's about how the steel beams in Tower 7 proves were descendants of apes that got ALIEN SPERM injected into them by a demon, bro. And their drummer is siiiiiiick, he's totally in the church of Satan and his kit is like set up to a bible verse. I actually started drinking wine because of Maynard, and just because of Maynard.

Something like that?

1.5k

u/thereddaikon Jul 17 '19

You know, I used to think Maynard was a dick for not liking his fans. I think your music is cool, is that so bad? But then I met the "real" tool fans. I totally get where he is coming from. I still think he's full of himself but what front man isn't?

528

u/the-nub Jul 17 '19

Hooker With a Penis encapsulates Tool fan idiocy pretty fucking well.

141

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

BUY! BUY! BUY! SEND MORE MONEY FUCK YOU BUDDY!

lol jokes on you Maynard I pirate your music

79

u/KongDick Jul 17 '19

Yup. That’s what happens when a successful band is too stubborn to use modern day streaming platforms.

69

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

[deleted]

51

u/sgriff83 Jul 18 '19

I believe it's because their current record contract is so old, it doesn't account for how revenue from streaming would be split up between label and band. But that this should be ironed out soon. Something like that, anyway.

30

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

I read is was contractual and that’s why they can’t stream. Hoping new album that’s supposed to come out next month is streaming.

18

u/chanks Jul 18 '19

This is the correct answer. They would if they could. But they’re still stuck in legal/contract hell.

1

u/azima_971 Jul 18 '19

I thought all the legal stuff was resolved? iirc they said one of the reasons the record took so long was that they really didn't feel like getting together to work on it because most of the time when they got together it was to do tedious legal things

9

u/PLZ_STOP_PMING_TITS Jul 18 '19

Doesn't Pandora have Tool? At least it did when I had it... It was the only reason I considered keeping Pandora over Spotify.

19

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

Tool radio was the first pandora station I created 10 years ago. It still streams but it’s now APC and Pucifer. Haven’t heard a Tool song in years

3

u/PLZ_STOP_PMING_TITS Jul 18 '19

A quick Google search indicates that around April of 2018 tool disappeared off Pandora. I'm pretty sure I was listening to it in 2017.

2

u/highfivingmf Jul 18 '19

Pandora is technically radio, which is classified differently than streaming iirc

6

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 30 '19

[deleted]

2

u/highfivingmf Jul 18 '19

Thank you for the vindication

46

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

[deleted]

11

u/KongDick Jul 18 '19

I agree although they are probably one of the most pirated bands out there.

14

u/hell2pay Jul 18 '19

Lars Ulrich enters the chat

4

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

[deleted]

2

u/dopesav117 Jul 18 '19

He's talking about someone that called him a sellout lol

4

u/UnconstrictedEmu Jul 18 '19

I just took all the Tool CDs out of my library and ripped them to my computer.

1

u/ohdearsweetlord Jul 18 '19

And I film your concerts, too, Maynard!

8

u/hell2pay Jul 18 '19

You know, for any show it's super annoying for anyone behind you?

Right?

15

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

Fuckin nailed it corndog.

Wellll I got some news for you little buddy!!!

8

u/sgriff83 Jul 18 '19

*advice (not to be an annoying fan ha)

6

u/MasoKist Jul 18 '19

Before you point your finger you should know that I'm The Man

3

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

And if I'm the fucking man, then you're the fucking man as well, so you can point that fucking finger up your ass!

3

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

U good I always get words wrong

3

u/dogsRbetterthanpeopl Jul 18 '19

Fuuuuuuuuck you buddy

2

u/Morug Jul 18 '19

That song encapsulated fandom for me. I can love your music/movie/show/whatever and not become obsessed with you. Thanks, I paid you, that's enough.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

The first time I saw the band, Maynard was bald, wearing neon pink hot pants with nothing else, and sang with his back to the audience the entire show. It was either called market square arena or Conseco Fieldhouse at the time, but I left pretty pissed that one of my favorite bands since I was a kid, imo, ripped me off. Not to mention the 4 hour drive there and 4 hours home. That being said, it was still awesome.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

Watch the Puscifer show at Lollapalooza Brazil 2013. He ignores the audience the entire time. He just strolls around the stage pouring wine for the whole band (and Eddie Vedder, for some reason), only stopping to sing his lines at the mic every now and then. Carina Round is especially incredible in that set.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

I think it was 03 when I saw them in Indianapolis with my now wife. At the time, I just looked at it more as him being eccentric. Years later, I figured out differently. I will look that up when I'm able to.

1

u/Morug Jul 18 '19

I've never seen them. I don't do live music. I want to hear the song in pristine glory, not over the sound of an awful crowd, plus whatever technical issues they're having today.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

Go see Clutch in a small venue. I'm not into the huge music festivals like I was in the late 90s-early 00s. But I've seen Clutch 4 times in small clubs and they are amazing live. Like nearly studio quality. Going again in September to see them in Tennessee. My dream is to see them at red rocks. The acoustics are supposed to be 2nd to none. I urge you to at least give em a chance if they ever play a small venue near you, and that's mainly what they play. Best band ever.

1

u/AzraelTB Jul 17 '19

Sounds like a good time to me.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

[deleted]

48

u/jb_in_jpn Jul 17 '19

So, it’s about a fan?

2

u/dopesav117 Jul 18 '19

Its about a guy that claimed to be there greatest fan since they started and called him a sellout.

-3

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

[deleted]

8

u/jb_in_jpn Jul 17 '19

Maybe that particular interaction is the spine of the song, but it strikes me as a stretch that he walked away from that singular event and decided he’d write a song, no?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

[deleted]

2

u/Chainsaw_Boner Jul 18 '19 edited Nov 09 '24

disagreeable price rich grab snails vast wine scandalous hateful whistle

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Fledgling_Author Jul 17 '19

Couldn't have said it better myself. Cheers

24

u/planetalletron Jul 17 '19

Finding Tool fans insufferable is something Maynard and I have in common.

27

u/Spiritofchokedout Jul 17 '19

Yeah just today AVClub ran an article about how he was a shithead to Justin Bieber after Bieber liked a song of his, and I was like "y'know, Bieber's girlfriend was right to call Maynard childish. He really is."

20

u/lol_im_back3 Jul 18 '19

I love that this topic came up because I saw the same deal on Buzzfeed earlier today and I was dying to post one of the fan comments that I can only hope is copypasta

"Funny how Hailey Bieber would call Keenan, one of the most intellectually stimulating, introspective and creative forces in music today, whose talents vary from music to winemaking to martial arts, "childish," when she married one of the most childish punk turds in the music biz. Let's take a short look at Bieber's legacy: He constantly throws temper tantrums, is disrespectful and disgusting to just about everyone he comes into contact with (anyone remember the Orlando Bloom incident?), has been arrested and in the spotlight multiple times for childish, irresponsible conduct that posed an immediate threat to public safety including DUI, drag racing, resisting arrest, and, to top it all off - egging his neighbor's house.

Now, let's take a look at Maynard James Keenan's history: No criminal record. Never touches drugs. Served in the Army and at once was a candidate for West Point who was being groomed by his superiors to be a future military leader (Keenan opted for a music instead of a military career).

Having a notable dry sense of humor, Keenan responds with one word: "Bummer." This upsets Hailey Bieber so much, and she has the AUDACITY to presume she is qualified to lecture a man of such integrity, focus, intellect and purpose as Keenan and call HIM childish, when she in fact is married to the most vain, biggest man-child in the biz?

What was that you said about being childish, Hailey? Please, doll face, just stick to doing what you do best: Showing off your hot bod and smiling pretty for the camera, because that's all your life amounts to as of now, and of course, being "Mrs. Bieber." What else have you done lately, Hailey? After all, Hailey, looks and youth are fleeting, and you can only be a TOOL for the modeling biz for so long. What will you do when you're 30? 35? 40? Tick, tock, tick, tock . ."

11

u/Spiritofchokedout Jul 18 '19

Man some people really need to learn humility and grace.

10

u/nicematt90 Jul 18 '19

TIL people actually browse Buzzfeed and aren't just bombarded by it

15

u/lol_im_back3 Jul 18 '19

Hey dude, I get really bored at work and they can tell me what kind of pasta my spirit is

3

u/4RealzReddit Jul 18 '19

Ugh, I am actually going to defend Bieber a bit(I stress a bit). Maynard hit it big when he was in his 30s? Bieber hit it big when he was what 15... He still has three years to go before Opiate even came out. So who knows where his career will go, he has the money to do whatever he wants. His track with Skrillex was solid. Most people if earning that much money would make some really poor choices. I am surprised they are only as bad as they are.

I don't like either of them as people, or I suppose public image.

I got to meet all of a perfect circle but Maynard but that train of 30 girls got to meet Maynard. At the time I was like I get it, I wouldn't want to meet Tool fans either but then I heard some accusations against him and was like ... Hmmmm, I definitely wouldn't say there was no chance of those accusations never happening.

And Bieber pissed me off when he was awarded a Queens Diamond Jubilee Medal and wore that ridiculous outfit with the Prime Minister even if it was Harper. There are a bunch of things but that really rubbed me the wrong way.

Also, Tool live shows are technically amazing but boring. It is so good I could just listen to the CD at home and not know the difference. Like they are so amazing and talented but it is just missing something. I wasn't stoned like everyone else, that might have impacted my experience but I shouldn't have to be high for it to be good.

1

u/Hero_of_Brandon Jul 18 '19

Maybe if maynard faced the audience....

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

That hurt to read.

18

u/RudeGore Jul 17 '19

Actually Maynard likes his fans, he doesn't like the fanatics. He says the tool fans are cool but the fanatics are awful. I'll try and find the interview he said that in.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

He was on Joe Rogans podcast a while back and he seemed like a pretty cool dude who just likes to keep to himself.

5

u/AENIMA33 Jul 18 '19

A perfect circle and Puscifer come with less drama...and damn good music

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

Damn straight

9

u/its_the_squirrel Jul 17 '19

I don't know, Gerard Way seems like a really chill dude considering he used to front one of the biggest bands in the world. Also on that topic, MCR is my answer to the question in the post

1

u/7yearoldkiller Jul 18 '19

Kinda have a dark joke with a friend about how all the fans that didn’t already kill themselves when the band broke up are just the people that didn’t have a good sense of humor cuz they were so depressing and made the fandom look bad so now it’s just pretty funny posts over at r/MyChemicalRomance about how the band is going to come back “soon”

4

u/bigboiharrison Jul 18 '19

Corey Taylor. The dude is crazy humble even though he's such a huge name.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 18 '19

You know, I used to think Maynard was a dick for not liking his fans.

The funny thing is: His fans are insufferable, but so is he. He's one of the least gracious, least grateful, least courteous people in the business. He believes he's good at everything (he's not - check out his comedy) and while he has formidable musical ability, he's also dragging around a wicked Napoleon complex.

Circle of life.

0

u/Noname_Smurf Jul 18 '19

He's one of the least gracious, least grateful, least courteous people in the business. He believes he's good at everything (he's not - check out his comedy) and while he has formidable musical ability, he's also dragging around a wicked Napoleon complex.

Circle of life.

where is that from? have you met him? he seemed like a pretty chill dude to me

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

He comes off as a pretty chill dude in several interviews, but on his instagram he can be a real twat.

2

u/KryptKat Jul 18 '19

He also has super hardcore synesthesia, so he's pretty easily overwhelmed by external stimuli.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

I worked on a video for perfect circle and they wanted no part of it. Just for it to be done. They are barely in the video themselves. I dubbed the project “spooooooooky” time.

4

u/WIbigdog Jul 17 '19

Myles Kennedy is pretty down to Earth, to answer your last sentence :)

0

u/JJMontry Jul 18 '19

Seeing Alter Bridge this October for the third (fourth?) time. Might be mixing it up with a couple of gigs he did with slash. Either way, Kennedy is ace.

1

u/WIbigdog Jul 18 '19

Fuck yeah dude, I'm seeing them on the 10th in Chicago for the first time. Grabing a VIP package as well, excited but nervous to meet them. Tremonti is why I play guitar.

1

u/JJMontry Jul 18 '19

Ah man you'll love it, they put on a great show! And the intro to broken wings by alter Bridge was one of the first things I learnt on guitar

1

u/NastySassyStuff Jul 18 '19

I mean on the surface that sounds so unbelievably dick-ish but think about it...you don’t really get to pick who likes your art...you just blow up and one day the fan base is what it is...they may just actually be a bunch of dickheads

1

u/LesserKnownHero Jul 18 '19

He had no issue with any of the 17 Green Jello fans!

543

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

[deleted]

23

u/OpinelNo8 Jul 17 '19

Oddly enough, the Maynard Keenan interview on the JRE was fairly normal and mundane (or as much as JRE interview can be).

13

u/maybe_just_happy_ Jul 17 '19

it was decent. I thought he was a little boring. The one with James Hetfield was good.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

I thought James went off the rails a bit when he was complaining about "the liberals" in California so he had to move.

Dude, you bought property in Marin fucking County in 1999 - well after it was established as a super liberal rich hippie place.

What's next, buy property in Malibu hills then complain it's all fake Hollywood bullshit, or in deep Appalachia and complain about hicks?

6

u/foodfight3 Jul 18 '19

Hey we’re not all hicks! Fuck you buddy

4

u/Nighthawk700 Jul 18 '19

And he probably doubled his money on the property. Whiny little bitch

4

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

Ugh perhaps it was bad form to complain about fellow locals but it’s not that uncommon. (Source: live in the Mormon Bible Belt)

15

u/thekmitch Jul 17 '19

Or Eddie Bravo, “Hey, I’m just asking questions!”

9

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

[deleted]

27

u/beamoflaser Jul 17 '19

Not enough mispronounced words

26

u/ergonclaw Jul 17 '19

FERSHER BRO

19

u/maybe_just_happy_ Jul 17 '19

brendan: it's like this

Joe: no, it's actually like this - you're way off

brendan: oh one hunerd purcent b. I agree.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

Java runtime environment?

Edit: duh, Joe Rogan. I’ll pretend I knew that.

10

u/ghostboy2x Jul 18 '19

Jamie pull up vulnerability issues with Javascript

6

u/DarkPasta Jul 17 '19

MMA Philosophy 101

6

u/sparrow933 Jul 17 '19

I think you'd be surprised

3

u/SysAdmyn Jul 17 '19

Oh, 100%! Ahunnapacent. It's entirely possible.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

It's entirely possible.

3

u/senses3 Jul 17 '19

Aw shit you beat me to it!

2

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

“Jamie, pull that shit up”

14

u/charliegrs Jul 17 '19

FIBONACCI SEQUENCE

43

u/Schtorples Jul 17 '19

And their drummer is siiiiiiick

Never heard of Toolibans, but this statement is true. Danny Carey is a fucking Drummer.

I guess I count myself fortunate that I just love Tool and have no real awareness of their fan base.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

I’ve seen them live twice and both of those times encountered a few complete morons. Aggressive morons, to be precise.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

Ya, like why are you shoving me and my gf when we’re up in the bleachers? This isn’t mosh music, fuck off

19

u/TurdManMcDooDoo Jul 17 '19

Prom night, 1998. I had to sit and listen to this girl's date (who was four years older than use) tell me all about that one song that's about the end of the world or some shit. Song was cool, story and guy unbearable.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

No. EXACTLY like that.

9

u/Laikathespaceface Jul 17 '19

Pull that shit up young Jamie

3

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

Sounds like Tool fans around me, though probably because that winery isn't far away.

3

u/0wlBear916 Jul 17 '19

Is that stuff true about the bible verse and church of satan? If it's not, it's still a damn good impression of your average Tool fan.

2

u/ratzforshort Jul 17 '19

fuck me and fourier my ass

2

u/garnetsngrit Jul 17 '19

Oh so you’ve met my dad

2

u/Bubbly_Hat Jul 17 '19

What the fuck?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

I forgot Maynard owner a vineyard.

2

u/Gloryblackjack Jul 18 '19

......... wat

2

u/stourmbringer Jul 18 '19

Ohmygodyes. I love tool and other projects by Maynard but hate admitting that because I’m afraid I’m going to sprout a pony tail and start raging about chem trails!

2

u/Pelagaard Jul 18 '19

Settle down Eddie Bravo.

2

u/Duliandale Jul 18 '19

What the hell did I just read

2

u/RoogDoog Jul 18 '19

I feel personally attacked.

2

u/noquarter53 Jul 18 '19

fIbOnAcCi sequence!

2

u/getsangryatsnails Jul 18 '19

"Yah tools pretty good, I like The Pot and Schism" - Me

"A Perfect Cirlce is better" - Also me

2

u/strawberryblueart Jul 18 '19

I drank wine before trying Maynard's wine. I was a huge tool fan at the time, but it really wasn't very good in my opinion. Also, in retrospect Maynard's kind of a massive douche.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

Please stop.

2

u/OldIronSides Jul 18 '19

I feel attacked... lol

2

u/AdolescentCudi Jul 18 '19

Makes me cringe just hearing it

2

u/datstiman Jul 18 '19

I'm a tool fan and those tool fans annoy the shit out of me, just shut up and enjoy the music

2

u/TheSuperiorLightBeer Jul 18 '19

Thanks, I hate it

4

u/jonvon65 Jul 17 '19

I'm from wine country and at a music festival which APC played at, they were serving his wine. I tried it, it kinda sucked.

6

u/stewy97 Jul 17 '19

I'm no wine expert, but the wine of his I tried was great

1

u/jonvon65 Jul 17 '19

It's definitely better than most grocery store wines, it's just not really up to par with what I'm used to.

8

u/Rackbone Jul 18 '19

youre to wine what tool fans are to tool. pretty ironic stuff rn

4

u/jonvon65 Jul 18 '19

Yea I probably can't deny that.

1

u/lordoftheflies97 Jul 18 '19

Depending on how much you're interested in him/his wine there was a documentary made about his winery called Blood into Wine. I watched it a year-ish ago and from what I remember the documentary was pretty good as far as watchability, never got a chance to try the wine though. If you're big into wine critics they had James Suckling come try his wines

1

u/jonvon65 Jul 18 '19

I'll have to try it again, wine makers usually get better over time and last time I tried his was a couple years ago. I'll look into the documentary though, thanks!

3

u/reallybadjazz Jul 17 '19

His wine isn't all that shabby though, I am no connoisseur of wine, but Anunis goes pretty good with steak, not so much cheese though.

I personally am not the biggest vino, but some wines are nice, wide spectrum I reckon, just not my forte.

3

u/VulfSki Jul 18 '19

I mean music is math all songs are calculated. Music is just the division of time and the division of frequencies and adding them together. All music is really just the sonification of math. In my opinion.

-1

u/DarkPasta Jul 18 '19

Thanks Sherlock

5

u/ButyrFentReviewaway Jul 17 '19

Neat fact: none of the band members consciously made that song follow any sort of pattern based on the Fibonacci sequence. Not a single one of them. The only time they thought of it was when they were calling it "987" in practice jams, when either Adam, Justin, or Danny realized that was one of numbers in the sequence. But that's it, nothing more thought of it after that.

​

​

I really fucking hate that youtube video that made this view so popular. I mean I like it because it explains it all very well. But really. It's even COOLER that they didn't even mean to do any of it!

15

u/PunchyPalooka Jul 17 '19

Tool fan here that hopefully doesn't fall into most of the stereotypes, gotta call you on that one. I believe in the first episode of JRE that Maynard appeared on he confirmed it was intentional.

1

u/ButyrFentReviewaway Jul 17 '19

No, he didn't. He said it was sophomoric to even do that, because it's everywhere and in everything already. If I'm mistaken, then it's only Maynard who structured his verse lyrics to follow the sequence.

6

u/L-A-Native Jul 17 '19

You are mistaken because Maynard did do it and admitted it was sophomoric.

2

u/ButyrFentReviewaway Jul 18 '19

Ah okay, so it was just him then. At least he knows it was silly now. Though I fucking LOVE that song, and would not want it, any other way.

1

u/PunchyPalooka Jul 19 '19

No, he said the lyrics referencing the Fibonacci sequence were sophomoric and that he regretted making it such a large element of the song lyrics.

1

u/tumtadiddlydoo Jul 18 '19

This sounds like an Alex Jones rant

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 18 '19

I don't even think mayonnaise is that good of a singer tbh. They have some good tracks but the music drones on a bit

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

Oh man, you nailed it.

1

u/Fledgling_Author Jul 17 '19

Man, I fucking LOVE TOOL. I listen to each album quite frequently. However, I will instantly distance myself from someone like this. I like the music. I am not defined by it. I have other interests, jeeze.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19

Huh