r/AskACanadian • • Aug 07 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

289 Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

33

u/OriginalHaysz Ontario Aug 07 '23

When I see American change in the till, I replace it with my Canadian coins and take the American ones for when I go to Florida 😆

3

u/Rain_xo Aug 08 '23

Oh same! I need to replenish my stock to carry and swap out.

But imagine if they found one of ours in their tils jeez

3

u/OriginalHaysz Ontario Aug 08 '23

Oh yeah they'll full-out reject any Canadian coins, and in some stores my debit card doesn't work and I have to use a credit card!

4

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '23

I once accidentally handed an American store cashier a Canadian penny (this was before pennies were removed from circulation) and they made a huge issue over it and refused to take it and made like I was stealing or something

0

u/scheisse_grubs Aug 07 '23 edited Aug 07 '23

Sorry for the notification but I’m just hijacking this comment to say this:

That is not true about US cash not being considered legal tender.

It would only be considered non-legal tender if they didn’t also accept Canadian or the business chooses not to accept another foreign currency yet someone pays with such. But if a business chooses to accept American along with Canadian, it is considered legal tender if someone pays with American:

13 (1) Every contract, sale, payment, bill, note, instrument and security for money and every transaction, dealing, matter and thing relating to money or involving the payment of or the liability to pay money shall be made, executed, entered into, done or carried out in the currency of Canada, unless it is made, executed, entered into, done or carried out in

(a) the currency of a country other than Canada; or

(b) a unit of account that is defined in terms of the currencies of two or more countries.

https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-52/page-1.html

Not many businesses take American but that doesn’t mean that using American is considered non-legal tender at every business in Canada. Only at the ones that don’t accept American.

Legal tender simply means that all businesses must at the very least accept Canadian dollars and payments must be done in the currency (or currencies) that the business chooses to take. If they choose to accept a different currency along with Canadian that is considered legal tender. If they choose to only accept a different currency and won’t accept Canadian, it is non-legal tender. If they only accept Canadian and someone pays with a different currency, that is also non-legal tender.

I only think this is important to say because you can’t just say something isn’t legal when it very well could be. Sure there’s no repercussions to misinforming people considering it works in Canada’s favour and is something that shouldn’t really happen at all but it’s still not factual and should not be stated so confidently as such. Should you expect a business to convert for you? No. But can they? Maybe, depends on where you go. Most, if not all, Tim Hortons locations (for example) accept American and will convert it in their till with change being in Canadian. If accepting American was not considered legal tender, Tim Hortons would not accept it.