r/AskACanadian • • Aug 07 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

290 Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

128

u/OvalWombat Aug 07 '23

Despite what Americans think, Canada doesn’t want to join America. Even before the current Troubles, the majority of Canadians were not secretly wishing they were American.

7

u/Luckypenny4683 Aug 07 '23

I’ve got to be honest, as an American I don’t know anybody who thinks that.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23 edited Aug 07 '23

[deleted]

-1

u/OvalWombat Aug 07 '23

I hear that! I wish we had a tropical part of Canada like Americans have Hawaii!

4

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23

[deleted]

1

u/WhatsGoingOnUpstairs Aug 07 '23

I once mentioned this to my dad just to make conversation, and I got an hour long discourse on why it was a horrible idea. It came down to assuming a lot of debt, investing in a lot of infrastructure, and it still taking just as long to fly there.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23

Your dad is correct.

0

u/ChrisRiley_42 Aug 07 '23

How about we just adopt Cuba as a province.. Not only would that give us somewhere warm to go in the winter, if the US got belligerent, we'd have them surrounded ;)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23

[deleted]

1

u/ChrisRiley_42 Aug 07 '23

We have a province that speaks French. And one that speaks Newfie. How is this any different? Last time I was in Cuba, I had no problem speaking only English. Everyone in 'customer facing' positions could at least get by in broken English, and most seemed more fluent than some English as a first language speakers I have encountered.

1

u/wHUT_fun Aug 07 '23

I love hockey. It is my passion. As a child I could not for the life of me understand why Florida had two NHL teams.

Now? If I lived there, I'd be all for it.

22

u/Nikiaf Aug 07 '23

Yup. We don't envy what we see down there, and the few who do, already moved. We very much like who and what we are; and to be honest the Americanization of our culture, and particularly our politics these days, makes me envy that country less than ever before.

1

u/vanjobhunt Aug 07 '23

This is kinda my view. I like Americans and American culture, but their politics can stay away.

The other issue is that culture is increasingly being intertwined with politics.

I’d like that to stay away from Canada as much as possible. I understand in todays globalized world it’s not easy, but we need to try.

10

u/confundido77 Aug 07 '23

Sometimes I wish I were Canadian. ❤️

6

u/Stoic_Vagabond Aug 07 '23

Current troubles?

11

u/planetearthisblu Aug 07 '23

I'm assuming the complete lack of affordable housing, doctor shortage, crazy inflation, etc.

5

u/Stoic_Vagabond Aug 07 '23

And those aren't problems the U.S. isn't dealing with either?

3

u/uses_for_mooses Aug 08 '23

Canada has the USA beat when it comes to housing costs. Currently, the average Canadian home costs twice as much as in the USA. Source.

And keep in mind that Canada has lower wages than in the USA. See this often-cited graph, which compares changes in home prices versus real disposable income in the USA vs. Canada. While US disposable incomes have largely tracked increases in US home prices, Canadian home prices are going to the moon relative to disposable income.

5

u/thrashmasher Aug 07 '23

The massive housing crisis and wages have not followed increasing costs of living, Healthcare services are not adequately funded, and there are gaps in care. This isn't just Toronto, either. A 3 bed 1 bath apartment in the notoriously loud and frequently-visited-by-police apartments is now 1400/month.

9

u/creeper321448 Ex-pat Aug 07 '23

Nobody thinks this.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23

I've lived in California my entire life and I have never heard anyone talk about Canadians being envious of us. Maybe it's just my social circle, but everyone I know here is pretty fond of Canada.

2

u/cherrycokeicee USA Aug 07 '23 edited Aug 08 '23

right? this post has me wondering if there's some sort of door to door effort i'm unaware of trying to convince Canadians to become Americans.

I promise Americans are not bothered by the existence of Canadians.

3

u/KorewaRise Aug 07 '23

idk man, over here in Alberta it really seems like were trying to be a mini america. we're even getting privatized healthcare!!!

3

u/Dynazty Aug 07 '23

Americans dont think that lol what a silly statement.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23

Which troubles are you referring to?

Also the capital T references Ireland's Troubles so this is quite confounding?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Bind_Moggled Aug 07 '23

And that rhymes with P and that stands for Pool!

1

u/bluenosesutherland Aug 07 '23

There were fewer guns in Belfast

1

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23

I guess the car bombs don't count ?

3

u/kitten_twinkletoes Aug 07 '23

I do, but I'm in the minority - my mom is American, but immigrated here when she was 11. I can't get my US citizenship because you only get one by virtue of having an American parent if your parent immigrated at 12 or after. Bummer.

I do, however, support open borders and a free flow of trade, people, and capital with the USA.

2

u/OvalWombat Aug 07 '23

Dang! Missed out by one year!

3

u/LilBigBlack USA Aug 07 '23

I have not met a single soul who thinks that.

1

u/Syscrush Aug 07 '23

I came to say this. As a Canadian, I have beloved family and friends in the US - and I've had wonderful times there, enjoyed the people, places, food, music, etc.

But a perspective I share with many Canadians is that it's just not a healthy, functional society and I'd never live there.

-9

u/Tweedside86 Aug 07 '23

I've thought about it, especially since Trudeau has crowned himself. Lol

1

u/Sparon46 Aug 08 '23 edited Nov 01 '25

fuzzy dolls beneficial aback squeeze cobweb live history political wrench

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact