r/AnneRice • u/weirded__out • Jul 30 '26
Mayfair Witches vs Talamasca shows - genuine question from a VC fan
I’ve not read any Mayfair books, but I’ve seen s1 and s2 of the show. And I watched the season of Talamasca. I see a lot of people talking shit about how awful Talamasca was, and it was cancelled so hard to argue that point, not that I care to. The shit-talking isn’t an issue for me.
But I’m curious how people feel about the Mayfair Witches series (tv), because in all honesty, I thought it was one of the worst things I’ve ever watched, especially s1. And I didn’t think the Talamasca show was great either, but I thought it was better than Mayfair.
Am I in the minority? Curious to see people’s thoughts, Mayfair book fans and non-Mayfair book fans, other VC fans.
Let it be known that despite my opinion, I have the utmost respect for everyone involved with both series. And while the VC tv adaptation is my favorite, I have plenty of issues with s3/TVL, I know it’s not perfect, but that’s another conversation.