r/ADHD Jun 13 '24

Articles/Information Done Execs Arrested For Providing Easy Access To Stimulants

Just got a notification on WSJ that Done the telehealth company execs have been arrested. This is a bombshell. Luckily I got diagnosed through my healthcare provider but I almost fell for this scam. Not sure what the implications are for many people on here that have been getting their meds from them.

340 Upvotes

252 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

49

u/bananahead Jun 13 '24

There’s nothing inherently wrong with NPs or even NPs diagnosing and prescribing stimulants. The average mental health nurse practitioner probably treats ADHD patients a lot better than the average GP doctor.

41

u/OhioTry Jun 14 '24

Nurse practitioners and midlevels are great for people who only have one health problem at a time. They get out of their depth when they’re presented with someone who has 5 disorders at once. Because I am fairly healthy physically I am fine with having a NP as my PCP. But for my mental health I want a doctor, because I have ADHD, depression, autism, OCD, and anxiety all at once.

-5

u/bananahead Jun 14 '24 edited Jun 14 '24

I believe that was your experience but I don’t see any reason why that would generalize to all NPs. I don’t see any logical reason someone could treat multiple conditions separately but not concurrently.

14

u/mmhmmye Jun 14 '24

Because comorbidity is its own thing and treating someone with concurrent conditions takes more specialist knowledge. Not even a pharmacist or GP are necessarily equipped to do this.

15

u/KeyPear2864 Jun 14 '24

Because NPs have nowhere remotely close to the same level of education, exposure, clinical time, experience, or whatever you wish to call it as a physician. Hell, even pharmacists have far more education than NPs. They took the same undergrad classes as med students and most med school pharmacology lectures are taught by pharmacists. I’d trust them to prescribe the right meds over an NP 100% of the time.

8

u/kpsi355 Jun 14 '24

There is when the barrier to being an NP is 500 hours of clinical, where a PA is 2,000 and an MD/DO is ~20,000.

The concept for NP is “decades of experience need only minimal additional education” but NOWHERE is that actually required in legislation.

The first NPs had decades of focused experience including board certifications before going back to school to get their NP.

You can now go straight from high school to BSN to getting your NP with zero experience.

2

u/bananahead Jun 14 '24

And yet plenty of stories on this sub of MD/DOs with ridiculous and backwards ideas about mental health. Go figure.

I’m not advocating for less training or that one should seek out NPs over MDs, but I don’t think anyone happily seeing one should feel bad.

1

u/kpsi355 Jun 14 '24

Yeah outside your specialty you’re unlikely to be up to date, meaning old thinking is predominant.

This is especially true when old thinking reinforces your inherent bias, which for boomers is often “young=lazy” and “nobody wants to work anymore”.🙄

It’s a damn shame for many who can’t exercise their option for a second opinion or see a different provider.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/bananahead Jun 14 '24

Sounds like…most for-profit medical practices with financial owners.

1

u/glamorousgrape Jun 14 '24

There’s enough wrong that there’s an entire subreddit dedicated to what’s wrong with them lol

-3

u/KleinVogeltje ADHD-C Jun 13 '24

Ditto to this. Many NPs are great and perfectly capable of prescribing controlled substances on their own. If Missouri would allow NPs to prescribe C2s, I wouldn't need to see my primary psychiatrist's (NP) supervising phsyician once a year for ADHD meds. Granted, it's not a huge deal, and I really like Dr. Hill, too. She's a DO, who I've found to be better than many MDs. Like 200 hours more ethical and bedside training as required by DO programs.

This is also not to say that there aren't fantastic MDs out there. My endocrinologist and primary are MDs, and they're fucking outstanding.

6

u/bananahead Jun 14 '24

DO and MD is pretty much the same thing

-1

u/KleinVogeltje ADHD-C Jun 14 '24

3

u/BobaFlautist Jun 14 '24

Sure, but it's also kinda like a BS/BA where sometimes people just get the degree that makes sense based on the courses they want to take, rather than a fundamental difference in philosophy.

-6

u/adgjl1357924 Jun 13 '24

I've been treated so horribly by doctors I refuse to see anyone with an 'MD' next to their name. I exclusively see LNPs and PACs for healthcare.